Board self-review
Boards review the CEO every year. Fewer review themselves. The board is the one group in the organisation nobody else can assess, so if it doesn't do it, nobody does. This is a twenty-statement self-review a board can run in a month: everyone scores it alone, the chair collates it, the board talks about the gaps once, and agrees two things to change.
This is an example for reference. Download the editable Word document below to make it your own. We'll email you a copy too.
What you get: Word document, 3 pages. Fill-in self-review first, chair's collation page and guide at the back.
It isn't the governance procedures review the Charities Act asks for every three years. That one checks your rules and procedures still fit. This one checks how the board is working. Do this every year and the three-yearly one is mostly done.
Score each statement 1 to 4: 1 isn't true, 2 is sometimes, 3 is mostly, 4 is always. No middle option, so nobody can sit on the fence.
The twenty statements
| # | Statement | 1 to 4 |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose and strategy | ||
| 1 | I can name our three strategic priorities without looking | |
| 2 | Our meetings spend more time on the future than on the past | |
| 3 | We know what's changed for the people we serve this year, with evidence | |
| 4 | We say no to things that don't fit the strategy | |
| Meetings and decisions | ||
| 5 | Papers arrive five working days out and I read them | |
| 6 | Every decision comes with a written recommendation | |
| 7 | We make decisions. Items don't roll from meeting to meeting | |
| 8 | Actions are owned, dated and done | |
| Board and CEO | ||
| 9 | We know where the board's job ends and the CEO's begins, and we stay on our side | |
| 10 | The CEO's report tells us what's wrong, not just what's right | |
| 11 | We review the CEO against goals we agreed in advance | |
| 12 | The CEO would say the board adds value, not just oversight | |
| Money and risk | ||
| 13 | Every board member can read the financial report and ask a useful question | |
| 14 | We know which funder or contract could sink us, and its status | |
| 15 | We've looked at the top five risks in the last three months | |
| 16 | We've asked the health and safety question in the last three meetings | |
| The board itself | ||
| 17 | Everyone contributes. No one person dominates the room | |
| 18 | We can disagree and leave as a board | |
| 19 | We have the skills we need, and we know the gap we're recruiting for | |
| 20 | New board members were properly inducted and felt useful within three meetings | |
Two open questions, answered in a sentence each
- The one thing this board should start doing.
- The one thing this board should stop doing.
How to run it
- 1
Chair sends it out after the first meeting of the year
Everyone, including the chair and the CEO. Two weeks to return it. Anonymous if the board is bigger than five; by name if it's smaller, because anonymity is fiction in a board of four.
- 2
Chair collates it on one page
Average score per statement, the spread (where one person scored 1 and another scored 4, that's the conversation), and the start and stop answers, grouped.
- 3
One agenda slot, thirty minutes, at the next meeting
No defending scores. Start with the lowest three statements and the widest spreads.
- 4
Agree two actions
Not five. One about how the board works, one about what it works on. Owner and date on each.
- 5
Put them in the board work plan
Check them in six months. Next year's review starts with: did we do the two things?
The rule
A review that produces a report and no change was a survey. Two actions, owned and dated, or it didn't happen.
The test
Look at statement 1. If more than one board member scored it below 3, stop reading the rest of the results. That's the action.
Goes with
| Use it with | Free resource |
|---|---|
| Carries the review's two actions into the year | Board annual work plan |
| Answers statement 19, the skills gap | Board skills matrix |
| Holds the date this review falls due | Annual governance calendar |
All of them are in the free resources library.
Get the printable version
Download this as a Word document
Pop in your email and we'll send you a copy and give you the printable version to hand out at your next board or team meeting.
We respect your privacy. Your details are used to send you this resource and occasional tips and resources. Untick the box above if you would rather not, and you can unsubscribe at any time. See our privacy policy.
Common questions
Questions about this resource
The procedures review is the statutory check of your rules and procedures every three years. This one checks how the board is working, and most boards run it every year.
Take the free organisational health check
Five minutes, thirty questions, and a personalised report across the eight areas of organisational health. It's free, with no obligation.
Take the organisational health check